Case Study

Aspiration vs Achievement: Board Diversity and Gender Pay in UK Insurance

IFoA General Insurance Spring Conference 2024. Presented by Michael Stefan, Partner, Hanover.

In this session, Michael Stefan compared what UK insurers say they want on diversity with what the data shows they have achieved.

The first part looked at the UK gender pay gap data from 2017 onwards for more than 130 UK insurance entities. It showed how the gap has changed over time and how many women are in the top pay quartile, and compared large and small insurers, and insurers and brokers.

The second part reviewed the board diversity policies of UK authorised insurers across personal lines, commercial lines and the Lloyd’s market. It covered the targets boards set, what those targets aimed for (gender, ethnicity or a wider mix), and how “tie-breaker” criteria are used when candidates are equally qualified. The session ended with a numbers-based view of how much gender diversity firms have actually achieved. This draws on anonymised PRA register data and Michael’s own Freedom of Information requests to the Bank of England.

Watch the recording here